Review: centromere-proximal positioning may explain why sex-linked regions stop recombining
A PLOS Genetics review by Deborah Charlesworth argues that low recombination near centromeres — rather than active suppression — may be sufficient to explain the evolution of large non-recombining sex-linked regions.
A review article published in PLOS Genetics by Deborah Charlesworth (University of Edinburgh) examines a long-standing question in evolutionary genetics: why do sex chromosomes so often carry large regions that do not recombine between the X and Y (or Z and W) chromosomes?
Conventional models have invoked positive selection for active suppression of recombination, often framed as an adaptation to keep together gene combinations that are advantageous in one sex. Charlesworth's review draws on recent high-quality genome sequences to argue that a simpler explanation may account for many cases: if the sex-determining locus happens to be positioned near a centromere, it will automatically experience low recombination rates as a consequence of the well-documented centromere effect — the tendency for meiotic crossovers to be suppressed in pericentromeric regions.
In this scenario, extensive sex-linked regions could arise as a pre-existing property of genome architecture, without requiring any active recombination suppression mechanism or debate about the selective forces involved.
The review (DOI: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1012333) is relevant to evolutionary geneticists, educators teaching chromosome biology and sex determination, and students learning about sex chromosome evolution. It also connects to broader questions about how chromosomal position shapes inheritance patterns — a topic relevant to genealogists and educators working with pedigree and inheritance concepts.
Sources
Read the original reporting — these are the public sources this summary draws from.
-
Primary source PLOS Genetics · 2026-10-27The peculiar properties of pericentromeric regions of genomes and their influence on sex chromosome evolution